Proscience Book a seat

Lecture 2 · Extract and Short Answer Practice · Note · Free

Notes — extract and question practice

1. How to write a good answer

1

Read the question and underline the key word, such as justify, analyse or evaluate.

2

Name the character or event at the start of your answer.

3

Give the point, then one detail from the play.

4

End with what it shows about the character or theme.

Important
Short answers should be about 40–50 words. Write in your own words and do not retell the whole play.

2. Quick revision of the friends' advice

FriendAttitudeAdvice to Shruti
PeterPracticalSimply tell your parents about the practice.
IqbalConfidentDo not worry; your father will understand.
AvinashDirectSilence will make it worse, so face it.

3. Extract practice: Set I

3

In the line 'Shruti hugs her parents', which word does not show what it conveys?

  1. Areconciliation
  2. Bharmony
  3. Cacceptance
  4. Dduty
  5. Eunderstanding
Answer
D duty
Explanation
The hug comes from love and relief, not from a sense of obligation.
4

What can be inferred about Shruti's future in music following her father's expression of trust and support?

Answer
Shruti will confidently follow her musical interests and balance classical and modern styles. Her father's support will encourage her to explore her talent without fear.
5

Complete the sentence: Nabin's final statement suggests that he now believes ............

Answer
different forms of music can coexist without conflict.
6

Complete the sentence: Shruti hugs her parents in order to ............

Answer
express her happiness, relief and gratitude for their understanding and support.

4. Extract practice: Set II

1

What fear does Nabin admit to in the extract?

Answer
Nabin admits that he feared Shruti would move away from their musical traditions and lose her connection with classical music through fusion performances.
2

What emotions are most appropriately conveyed by the phrases 'I trust you' and 'I will root for your group'?

  1. (i)gratitude (ii) pride (iii) support (iv) encouragement (v) inspiration
  2. (a)(i) and (ii)
  3. (b)(ii), (iii) and (iv)
  4. (c)(iii), (iv) and (v)
  5. (d)(iii) and (v)
Answer
B (ii), (iii) and (iv)
3

Complete the sentence: The phrase 'each bay, its own wind' in the extract reflects ............

Answer
the idea that each individual has their own path and style.
4

What can be inferred about Nabin's attitude towards Shruti at the end of the extract?

Answer
Nabin shows acceptance and trust. He supports her decision and is confident in her abilities.
5

Identify the phrase that refers to the uniqueness of each artist's journey and style.

Answer
'each bay, its own wind'

5. Short answer questions: Textual

1

Justify the title "Twin Melodies". How does the play explore the theme of tradition and modernity?

Answer
"Twin Melodies" refers to two styles, Hindustani classical and Indo-Western fusion, which stand for tradition and modernity. Shruti carries both, while Nabin guards the old. By the end, father and daughter accept each other, showing that the old and the new can exist in harmony.
2

What are the different perspectives of Peter, Iqbal and Avinash regarding confronting figures of authority? How do their attitudes towards Shruti's dilemma with her father provide insight into their own characters and values?

Answer
Peter advises her simply to tell her parents about the practice, which is a practical step. Iqbal is confident that Nabin will understand. Avinash feels silence will worsen matters, so she must face it. Together they show honesty, courage and belief in open communication.
3

Analyse the character of Nabin Sharma. How does his attitude towards music evolve throughout the play?

Answer
Nabin is a strict, disciplined musician devoted to Hindustani classical music. At first he rejects fusion, fearing it will harm artistic purity. After hearing Shruti keep the essence of the raga, and after Leela reminds him of his own past, he accepts and supports her.
4

How does the play use Shruti's internal conflict to explore the theme of duty towards family versus personal passion?

Answer
Shruti respects her father but also loves fusion music. She fears hurting him, yet wants to explore new forms. This tension shows duty clashing with passion. Her honesty and his final understanding show that personal dreams can exist alongside family values through respect and communication.
5

Evaluate the effectiveness of the play's conclusion. Does it realistically address the conflicts presented?

Answer
The ending works because Nabin changes through what he hears and understands, not through force. Shruti is ready to give up fusion, and then her father accepts it. The conflict ends realistically because respect for tradition remains, while space is made for new ideas.
6

Assess how well the role of cultural diversity contributes to the storyline of the play.

Answer
Cultural diversity runs through the play. Iqbal, Peter and Avinash bring different musical influences, and fusion music unites Hindustani and Western styles. The group becomes a symbol of unity. Shruti's interest shows that new forms can be accepted while classical roots are still respected.

6. Short answer questions: Additional

7

What news is reported in the Parbatpuri Daily Clarion, and how does it contribute to the mood of the story? (Or: Explain how the news reported in the Parbatpuri Daily Clarion shapes the mood of the story.)

Answer
The Parbatpuri Daily Clarion praises Shruti for performing with her father and calls her a talented musician. The news is a happy moment, but Shruti feels anxious about the coming fusion concert. This contrast adds tension and makes the mood both proud and uneasy.
8

Avinash asks Shruti if she has told Nabin sir about the fusion performance. How does her reaction reveal the inner conflict between her father's expectations and her own interests?

Answer
Shruti's hesitation shows she is torn. She has not told her father because she fears his disapproval and does not wish to upset him. Yet she wants to explore fusion music. Her nervousness reveals the struggle between obeying him and following her own interest.
9

What does Shruti's fear reveal about Guru Nabin Sharma's personality and beliefs? (Or: How do Guru Nabin Sharma's strict views on music affect Shruti's behaviour and feelings?)

Answer
Shruti's fear shows Nabin is a strict musician deeply devoted to the purity and discipline of Hindustani classical music. She respects him so much that she delays telling him about fusion. Her nervous silence shows how strongly his views shape her behaviour and feelings.

Come and see us

Message us on WhatsApp and we will answer the same day.