Lecture 1 · Twin Melodies · Note · Free
Notes
About the play
Playwright: Mitra Phukan | Form: one-act play in three acts | Textbook: Kaveri, Class 9
Characters
| Character | Who they are |
|---|---|
| Shruti Sharma | Young aspiring violinist; plays in a fusion group |
| Guru Nabin Sharma | Shruti's father, master violinist, Principal of Sangeetika Music School |
| Leela Devi | Shruti's mother |
| Avinash | Tabla player of the group |
| Iqbal | Flutist; the practice room is his |
| Peter | Keyboard player |
Act I — At Iqbal's room
- Setting: a small rack, a wooden table stacked with books; posters of flute players Pandit Hariprasad Chaurasia and Shashank Subramanyam on the wall.
- The four friends finish a fusion rehearsal. Iqbal reads out a newspaper's praise of Shruti's performance with her father.
- Shruti looks distressed — she has not told her father about the fusion concert.
- She fears he will see playing the violin to Western tunes as a desecration; he believes only classical music, with its ragas and aalaaps, is worthy.
- She cares about his opinion but wants to try fusion too.
- Her friends encourage her; she decides to bite the bullet and promises to bring it up at dinner.
Act II — At the dinner table
- Shruti is absent-minded, staring at her dosa. Leela teases her gently.
- When Shruti mentions a concert, Nabin says "no" firmly — his rule is one performance in six months.
- On hearing it is a group fusion concert, he is disappointed; he mocks fusion as 'phoo' music and leaves.
- Leela scolds Shruti for hiding her practice. Shruti apologises and promises not to hide things again.
Act III — Back at Iqbal's house
- In an aside, Shruti plans to practise one last time and then quit the group.
- Her parents quietly come in, become engrossed, and Nabin taps his feet. He claps with pride and praises Shruti for never losing the notes of the raga.
- He offers the children the music room for practice.
- Leela reveals that Nabin himself had gone against his family of vocalists to play the violin, a Western instrument, and worked very hard.
- Nabin admits his fears were baseless: "each bay, its own wind". He will root for the group. Shruti hugs her parents.
Themes
- Tradition vs modernity — classical and fusion music can live together.
- Generation gap — parents and children see art differently.
- Duty to family vs personal passion — Shruti respects her father yet follows her interest.
- Friendship and encouragement — the friends give Shruti courage.
- Cultural diversity — Avinash, Iqbal, Peter and Shruti come from different backgrounds and make music together.
- History repeating — Nabin once faced the same struggle as Shruti.
Character sketches
- Shruti: talented, respectful, sensitive, hesitant at first but honest; she grows in courage.
- Nabin: strict, disciplined, devoted to classical music, proud; initially rigid and mocking but finally open-minded and loving.
- Leela: humorous, wise, a peacemaker; scolds Shruti for hiding things but helps Nabin see the truth.
- The friends: Iqbal is light-hearted and reassuring, Avinash is practical and direct, Peter is cheerful and focused on practice.
Words and phrases
| Word / phrase | Meaning |
|---|---|
| crescendo | music that gets louder and louder |
| desecration | disrespect towards something sacred |
| ragas and aalaaps | elements of Hindustani classical music |
| bite the bullet | face a difficult situation bravely |
| contempt | strong dislike and disrespect |
| familiarity breeds contempt | too much exposure makes people value something less |
| hubbub | a loud noise |
| iterated | repeated |
| painstakingly | with great care and effort |
| worked his fingers to the bone | worked very hard |
| root for | show support |
| go down the drain | be wasted |
| come round | change one's opinion and agree |
| each bay, its own wind | every person has a unique path |
Dramatic devices
- In a script, a colon follows the speaker's name; no inverted commas are used.
- Ellipsis (…) shows a pause or hesitation.
Textbook answers
Reflect and Respond IV (idioms):
- 1 winding up · 2 wearing a look of distress · 3 lost in his thoughts · 4 bring it up · 5 bite the bullet · 6 come around · 7 found words · 8 throw a party (extra: sweating on)
Act I table:
- Room: small rack, wooden table stacked with books | Wall: posters of Pt Hariprasad Chaurasia and Shashank Subramanyam
- Iqbal – flute, Avinash – tabla, Peter – keyboard, Shruti – violin
- "You are a sensation now…" — Avinash; the newspaper had praised Shruti's performance.
- "There is need to worry…" — Shruti; her father is strict and dislikes fusion music.
- "That's the spirit!" — Peter; Shruti promised to tell her father at dinner.
Act II summary:
- 1 absent-minded · 2 courage · 3 disapproval · 4 plea · 5 firm · 6 scolded · 7 clash · 8 setback (extra: surprised, relief)
Act III true/false:
- 1 True · 2 True · 3 False (he praised her; she played, not sang) · 4 False (his family were vocalists) · 5 True · 6 True
Extract 1: (i) D — in a dilemma | (ii) telling him gently and respectfully, without hurting him | (iii) the father sees only classical music as worthy, while the daughter wants to explore new forms | (iv) Iqbal assures her that a loving father will understand however she tells him | (v) of any worth
Extract 2: (i) B — traditional values and modern expressions | (ii) losing her connection to her roots / tradition | (iii) duty | (iv) she will grow confidently with her family's support, in both classical and fusion music | (v) each bay, its own wind
Vocabulary:
- Aside: (iv) (i), (ii) and (iii)
- Fillers are used to fill gaps while speaking (1). Emoticons: 1 arrgh · 2 ahem-ahem · 3 err · 4 hmmm (extra: whew)
- Matching: 1-(iii) · 2-(iv) · 3-(i) · 4-(v) · 5-(ii) · 6-(vii) · 7-(vi)
- drown your individual style: lose your own uniqueness | sense of musicality: natural feel and talent for music | go down the drain: be wasted
- Sentences 1 and 2 are exclamatory. Declarative: Shruti exclaimed that she enjoyed performing that piece very much. / Nabin exclaimed with admiration that it was very soulful and that they had all done a wonderful job.
Reported speech:
- Iqbal exclaimed that it was an incredible achievement and that he could not believe they had pulled it off.
- Shruti's mother applauded that each note had been executed perfectly and the performance had been flawless.
- Iqbal exclaimed that he basically had a little bit of scolding for breakfast every day.
- Shruti apologised to her mother and promised that she would not hide from her again.
- Avinash exclaimed that Shruti was a sensation then and that the least she could do was throw a party.
- Asma: 1 had had a unique experience at the art studio that day · 2 she had accidentally spilled paint all over her canvas · 3 the painting then looked better than her original plan · 4 it was incredible