Proscience Book a seat

Lecture 2 · Emergency of 1975 · Note · Free

The Crisis of Democratic Order — Emergency of 1975 | Notes

The Crisis of Democratic Order — Lecture: From Unrest to Emergency and Its Lessons

Class 12 Political Science | Humanities 2027 | NCERT pp. 96–103

1. Background: Popular agitations and Jayaprakash Narayan

Gujarat and Bihar witnessed major agitations against state governments. Jayaprakash Narayan (JP) emerged as an alternative opposition leader. Indira Gandhi and the Congress criticised these movements as politically motivated attempts to challenge her leadership rather than only the state governments.

2. Railway Strike of 1974

In May 1974, the National Coordination Committee for Railwaymen’s Struggle, led by George Fernandes, called a nationwide railway strike demanding bonuses and improved service conditions. Rail transport was vital for goods and passengers. The government opposed the demands, declared the strike illegal, arrested leaders and deployed the Territorial Army to protect tracks. The strike ended after 20 days without settlement. It raised questions about workers’ rights and strikes in essential services.

3. Conflict with the Judiciary

Disagreements centred on whether Parliament could restrict Fundamental Rights, limit the right to property and prioritise Directive Principles over Fundamental Rights. In Kesavananda Bharati (1973), the Supreme Court ruled that Parliament may amend the Constitution but cannot alter its basic structure. In 1973, the government appointed Justice A. N. Ray Chief Justice, superseding three senior judges; this sparked controversy over judicial independence and the idea of a ‘committed judiciary’.

4. Indira Gandhi Election Case

On 12 June 1975, Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha of the Allahabad High Court invalidated Indira Gandhi’s 1971 Lok Sabha election following a petition by Raj Narain alleging misuse of government servants in her campaign. On 24 June 1975, the Supreme Court granted a partial stay: she could remain an MP pending appeal but could not participate in Lok Sabha proceedings. JP and opposition parties demanded her resignation; on 25 June JP addressed a massive rally at Delhi’s Ramlila grounds and called for peaceful resistance to illegal and immoral orders.

5. Declaration of Emergency

On 25 June 1975, the government proclaimed an Emergency on the ground of internal disturbance under Article 352 (as worded then). Prime Minister Indira Gandhi recommended it to President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, who issued the proclamation. The Cabinet was informed at a meeting the following morning. Emergency powers strengthened the Union executive and enabled extensive restrictions on civil liberties.

6. Consequences

Opposition leaders were jailed; strikes, protests and public agitations were prohibited; press freedom was curtailed through pre-publication censorship; RSS and Jamaat-e-Islami were banned. Fundamental Rights enforcement was severely restricted, including access to courts for certain remedies. Preventive detention was widely used. In ADM Jabalpur (1976), the Supreme Court accepted the government's position denying judicial relief for unlawful detention during the Emergency, a judgment widely criticised.

Resistance included underground pamphlets, newspapers leaving blank spaces to protest censorship, and writers such as Shivarama Karanth and Fanishwarnath Renu returning national honours.

7. Constitutional Changes

During the Emergency, constitutional amendments attempted to shield elections of top office-holders from judicial challenge. The 42nd Amendment (1976) made extensive changes, including extending Lok Sabha and state assembly terms from five to six years. Elections could also be postponed during Emergency. These changes illustrate the concentration of power in the period.

8. Lessons of the Emergency

(i) Democracy in India showed resilience as normal democratic politics returned. (ii) Emergency safeguards were subsequently tightened: ‘internal disturbance’ was replaced by ‘armed rebellion’, and written advice of the Union Cabinet became necessary for proclamation. (iii) Civil liberties, judicial oversight and an independent press became central concerns. (iv) The period exposed the danger of politicising the police and administration, and raised the difficult question of balancing public protest and orderly government.

9. Quick Revision Timeline
DateEvent
May 1974Nationwide railway strike
1973Kesavananda Bharati; A. N. Ray appointment
12 June 1975Allahabad High Court judgment
24 June 1975Partial Supreme Court stay
25 June 1975JP rally and Emergency proclamation
1976ADM Jabalpur judgment; 42nd Amendment
Exam tip: Distinguish the legal grounds for declaring Emergency at the time (‘internal disturbance’) from the post-Emergency constitutional safeguard (‘armed rebellion’).

Come and see us

Message us on WhatsApp and we will answer the same day.